HOME ~ Contact us

Gilbert de Clare and Joan of Acre

HUSBAND:
Gilbert de CLARE. 7th Earl of Gloucester, 6th Earl of Hertford, 9th Earl of Clare, 3rd Lord of Glamorgan.
Born on 2 September 1243 at Christchurch, Hampshire, England; son of Richard de CLARE and Maude de LACY. Also known as "Red" Gilbert de Clare or "The red earl", probably because of his hair colour or fiery temper in battle.

Gilbert inherited his father's estates in 1262. He took on the titles, including Lord of Glamorgan, from 1263. Being under age at his father's death, he was made a ward of Humphrey de Bohun, 2nd Earl of Hereford. He held the Lordship of Glamorgan which was one of the most powerful and wealthy of the Welsh Marcher Lordships as well as over 200 English manors (172 in the Honor of Clare). (S2).

In April 1264, Gilbert de Clare led the massacre of the Jews at Canterbury,[4] as Simon de Montfort had done in Leicester. Gilbert de Clare’s castles of Kingston and Tonbridge were taken by the King, Henry III. However, the King allowed de Clare's Countess Alice de Lusignan, who was in the latter, to go free because she was his niece; but on 12 May de Clare and de Montfort were denounced as traitors. (S2).

just before the Battle of Lewes, on 14 May, Simon de Montfort knighted the Earl and his brother Thomas. The Earl commanded the central division of the Baronial army, which formed up on the Downs west of Lewes. When Prince Edward had left the field in pursuit of Montfort's routed left wing, the King and Earl of Cornwall were thrown back to the town. Henry took refuge in the Priory of St Pancras, and Gilbert accepted the surrender of the Earl of Cornwall, who had hidden in a windmill. Montfort and the Earl were now supreme and de Montfort in effect de facto King of England. (S2).

On 20 October 1264, Gilbert and his associates were excommunicated by Pope Clement IV, and his lands placed under an interdict.[citation needed] In the following month, by which time they had obtained possession of Gloucester and Bristol, the Earl was proclaimed to be a rebel. However at this point he changed sides as he fell out with de Montfort and the Earl, in order to prevent de Montfort's escape, destroyed ships at the port of Bristol and the bridge over the River Severn at Gloucester.[citation needed]Having changed sides, de Clare shared the Prince's victory at Kenilworth on 16 July, and in the Battle of Evesham, 4 August, in which de Montfort was slain, he commanded the second division and contributed largely to the victory.[citation needed]On 24 June 1268 he took the Cross at Northampton in repentance and contrition for his past misdeeds. (S2).

In October 1265, as a reward for supporting Prince Edward, Gilbert was given the castle and title of Abergavenny and honour and castle of Brecknock. At Michaelmas his disputes with Llewelyn the Last were submitted to arbitration, but without a final settlement. Meanwhile, he was building Caerphilly Castle into a fortress.[5] At the end of the year 1268 he refused to obey the King's summons to attend parliament, alleging that, owing to the constant inroads of Llewelyn the Last, his Welsh estates needed his presence for their defence. At the death of Henry III, 16 November 1272, the Earl took the lead in swearing fealty to Edward I, who was then in Sicily on his return from the Crusade. The next day, with the Archbishop of York, he entered London and proclaimed peace to all, Christians and Jews, and for the first time, secured the acknowledgment of the right of the King's eldest son to succeed to the throne immediately.Thereafter he was joint Guardian of England, during the King's absence, and on the new King's arrival in England, in August 1274, entertained him at Tonbridge Castle. (S2).

During Edward's invasion of Wales in 1282, de Clare insisted on leading an attack into southern Wales. King Edward made de Clare the commander of the southern army invading Wales. However, de Clare's army faced disaster after being heavily defeated at the Battle of Llandeilo Fawr. Following this defeat, de Clare was relieved of his position as the southern commander and was replaced by William de Valence, 1st Earl of Pembroke (whose son had died during the battle). (S2).

In the next year, 1291, he quarrelled with the Earl of Hereford, Humphrey de Bohun, 3rd Earl of Hereford, grandson of his onetime guardian, about the Lordship of Brecknock, where de Bohun accused de Clare of building a castle on his land culminated in a private war between them. Although it was a given right for Marcher Lords to wage private war the King tested this right in this case, first calling them before a court of their Marcher peers, then realising the outcome would be coloured by their likely avoidance of prejudicing one of their greatest rights they were both called before the superior court, the Kings own. At this both were imprisoned by the King, both sentenced to having their lands forfeit for life and de Clare, the Earl of Gloucester, as the aggressor, was fined 10,000 marks, and the Earl of Hereford 1,000 marks.They were released almost immediately and both of their lands completely restored to them - however they had both been taught a very public lesson and their prestige diminished and the King's authority shown for all. (S2).

Gilbert's first marriage was to Alice de Lusignan, also known as Alice de Valence, the daughter of Hugh XI of Lusignan and of the family that succeeded the Marshal family to the title of the Earl of Pembroke in the person of William de Valence, 1st Earl of Pembroke. They married in 1253, when Gilbert was ten years old. She was of high birth, being a niece of King Henry, but the marriage floundered. Gilbert and Alice separated in 1267; allegedly, Alice's affections lay with her cousin, Prince Edward. Previous to this, Gilbert and Alice had produced two daughters. (S2).

After his marriage to Alice de Lusignan was annulled in 1285, Gilbert married Joan of Acre, a daughter of King Edward I of England and his first wife Eleanor of Castile. King Edward sought to bind de Clare, and his assets, more closely to the Crown by this means. By the provisions of the marriage contract, their joint possessions and de Clare's extensive lands could only be inherited by a direct descendant, i.e. close to the Crown, and if the marriage proved childless, the lands would pass to any children Joan may have by further marriage. On 3 July 1290, the Earl gave a great banquet at Clerkenwell to celebrate his marriage of 30 April 1290 with Joan of Acre (1272 - 23 April 1307) after waiting for the Pope to sanction the marriage. Edward then gave large estates to Gilbert, including one in Malvern. Disputed hunting rights on these led to several armed conflicts with Humphrey de Bohun, 3rd Earl of Hereford, that Edward resolved. Gilbert made gifts to the Priory, and also had a "great conflict" about hunting rights and a ditch that he dug, with Thomas de Cantilupe, Bishop of Hereford, that was settled by costly litigation. Gilbert had a similar conflict with Godfrey Giffard, Bishop and Administrator of Worcester Cathedral (and formerly Chancellor of England. Godfrey, who had granted land to the Priory, had jurisdictional disputes about Malvern Priory, resolved by Robert Burnell, the then Chancellor. Thereafter, Gilbert and Joan are said to have taken the Cross and set out for the Holy Land. In September, he signed the Barons' letter to the Pope, and on 2 November, surrendered to the King his claim to the advowson of the Bishopric of Llandaff. (S2).

He died at Monmouth Castle on 7 December 1295, and was buried at Tewkesbury Abbey, on the left side of his grandfather Gilbert de Clare. His extensive lands were enjoyed by his surviving wife Joan of Acre until her death in 1307. Gilbert and Joan had a descendant named Ursula Hildyard of Yorkshire, who in 1596 married (Sir) Richard Jackson of Killingwoldgraves, near Beverley in the East Riding.[citation needed] Jackson died in 1610 and was interred at Bishop Burton. In 1613, James posthumously awarded a coat of arms and a knighthood to Richard for meretorious military service in the Lowlands of Scotland. (S2).

WIFE (1):
Alice de Lusignan, also known as Alice de Valence,.
Daughter of Hugh XI of Lusignan and of the family that succeeded the Marshal family to the title of the Earl of Pembroke in the person of William de Valence, 1st Earl of Pembroke

CHILDREN of Gilbert de Clare and Alice de Lusignan:
  1. Isabella de Clare (10 March 1262 – 1333), after a marriage with Guy de Beauchamp, 10th Earl of Warwick having b1een contemplated, or possibly having taken place and then annulled, married Maurice de Berkeley, 2nd Baron Berkeley.
  2. Joan de Clare (1264-after 1302), married (1) Duncan Macduff, 7th Earl of Fife; (2) Gervase Avenel.


WIFE (2):
Joan of ACRE. (Joanna). [CHART A1].
Born 1272 at Acre (Akko), Israel, daughter of EDWARD I and Eleanor of Castile. She married (1) Gilbert de CLARE, 7th Earl of Hertford, 3rd of Gloucester on 2 May 1290 (His Age: 47 Her Age: 18) at Westminster Abbey, London, England.

She married (2) Ralph Morthermer, Earl of Gloucester and Hertford, about January 1297 (Her Age: 25).

Ralph de Monthermer was a member of her first husband's household. Complete Peerage, 5 (1926): 709-710 (sub Gloucester) says the following regarding this marriage and Ralph's parentage:

"She [Joan] married, 2ndly, clandestinely, to her father's great displeasure, presumably early in 1297, Ralph de Monthermer, a member of the late Earl's household. On 29 Jan. 1296/7 the escheator was ordered to take into his hand all the lands, goods and chattels of Joan, Countess of Gloucester, from which it might be inferred that theKing, suspecting her intentions with regard to Monthermer, sought to coerce her to abandon the marriage by degradation and loss of estates. On 16 March the King gave his assent to her marriage with Amadeus of Savoy, and therefore must have been ignorant of her marriage, if it had already taken place, and on 12 May it was ordered that Joan should have reasonable allowance for herself and children.

It would seem that by 3 July the King had discovered Joan's marriage with Monthermer, for he took her lands into his own hand, but by 31 July, when he certainly knew of the marriage, he appears to have been partly mollified, for her lands were restored (except Tonbridge); in ordering her to provide 100 men to serve in France, however, the special proviso was made that they might be commanded by anyone except Ralph de Monthermer, her husband. She was pardoned two days later, 2 August 1297."

"Ralph de Monthermer, whose parentage is unknown, is said to have come from the bishopric of Durham. He was in the household of Gilbert, Earl of Gloucester and Hertford, whose widow Joan appears to have been attracted by his personal charms, and to have obtained a knighthood for him. He married the said Joan, daughter of Edward I, apparently some time early in 1297, as mentioned above. The King, on discovering the marriage, was extremely angry, and imprisoned Monthermer in Bristol, but by the intercession of prelates and magnates he was reconciled to Monthermer, who had pardon and did homage to the King and Prince Edward 2 August 1297 at Eltham ... In consequence of his marriage and as tenant of his wife's estates, he was styled Earl of Gloucester and Hertford during her life, but never acquired full comital rank .... he lost the name of Earl at his wife's death." END OF QUOTE.

As we can see, the parentage and ancestry of Sir Ralph de Monthermer are completely unknown. Moreover, no trace of Sir Ralph de Monthermer has been found in Durham records. However, an excellent clue to Sir Ralph de Monthermer's origin was recently pointed out by Andrew MacEwen, of Maine, the expert on all things Scottish. According to MacEwen, on 28 October 1303, a safe conduct was granted as Skamskynel to Ralph de Monthermer, Earl of Gloucester, and to his "bachelor and cousin," Sir John Bluet [Reference: Joseph Bain, Calendar of Documents relating to Scotland, 4 (1888): 370]. This record appears to have been completely overlooked by Complete Peerage.

The Sir John Bluet named in this record would surely be the Sir John Bluet, died 1317, of Silchester, Hampshire and Lacock, Wiltshire, which Sir John is a lineal descendant of the Ralph Bluet, of same, who married c. 1150 Isabel de Beaumont, widow of Gilbert Fitz Gilbert, Earl of Pembroke. For particulars of this Sir John Bluet, see the brief account of him in VCH Hampshire, Volume 4, which is available at the following weblink: http://www.british-history.ac.uk/report.asp?compid=56744

Inasmuch as the given name, Ralph, occurs repeatedly in the Bluet family, it seems quite possible that Sir Ralph de Monthermer obtained his given name through his connection to the Bluet family. Sir John Bluet had a grandfather, great-grandfather, uncle, and brother all named Ralph. So the name Ralph definitely ran in this branch of the Bluet family.

However, an alternate suggestion is also provided: Given that Sir John Bluet is identified as the 'bachelor and cousin' of Ralph Monthermer in 1303, John Bluet was clearly junior in age to Ralph in age (and rank) at that time. There are pedigrees of the Bluet family which allege a marriage of Ralph Bluet to a "Llowis, sister of Gilbert de Monthermer, Earl of Hereford and Gloucester" [Vivian's Vis. Cornwall, "Blewett of Colan"] or to "Avis, sister of Gilbert de Monthermer" [Vis. Devon, 1564, "Blewett"]. Specific errors in these identifications are obvious, but the implication that Ralph de Monthermer had a sister married to Ralph Bluet leads one to surmise that John Bluet was most likely a nephew (presumably "consanguineus" in the original Latin text as translated in Bain), and not 'cousin' (modern definitiion), of Ralph de Monthermer.

She died on 23 April 1307 at Clare, Suffolk, England.

CHILDREN of Gilbert de Clare and Joan of Acre:
  1. Gilbert de Clare. Gilbert, Earl of Hertford and Gloucester (1291–1314) succeeded to his father's titles and was killed at the Battle of Bannockburn.
  2. Eleanor de Clare. Eleanor de Clare (1292–1337) married (1) Hugh Despenser the Younger, favourite of her uncle Edward II. Hugh was executed in 1326, and Eleanor married (2) William de la Zouche.
  3. Margaret de CLARE. Born (1292-S1)(1293-S2). Margaret married (1) Piers Gaveston (executed in 1312). She married (2) Hugh de Audley. She died on 13 April 1342.
  4. Elizabeth de Clare. Elizabeth (1295–1360) married (1) John de Burgh in 1308 at Waltham Abbey. She married (2) Theobald of Verdun in 1316. She married (3) Roger d'Amory in 1317. Each marriage was brief, produced one child (a son by the 1st, daughters by the 2nd and 3rd), and left Elizabeth a widow.


SOURCES:

HOW ARE WE RELATED:

Gilbert de Clare and Joan of Acre
Margaret de Clare and Hugh de Audley
Margaret de Audley and (Sir) Ralph de Safford
Hugh de Stafford and Philippa de Beauchamp
Edmund de Stafford and Ann of Gloucester
Humphrey Stafford and Anne Neville
Margaret Stafford and Robert Dunham
John Dunham and Elizabeth Bowett
John Dunham II and Jean Thorland
John Dunham III and Benedict Folgamsee
Ralph Dunham and Elizabeth Wentworth
Thomas Dunham and Jane Bromley
John Dunham Sr. and Susannah Kenney
John Dunham, Jr. and Mary
Mary Dunham and James Hamblin, Jr. 
Elkenah Hamblin and Abigail Hamblin
Sylvanus Hamblin and Dorcas Fish
Barnabus Hamblin and Mary Bassett
Isaiah Hamblin and Daphne Haynes
Jacob Vernon Hamblin and Sarah Priscilla Leavitt
Ella Ann Hamblin and Warren Moroni Tenney
Clive Vernon Tenney and Minnie Williams
Mildred Ella Tenney and Glenn Russell Handy
Deborah Lee Handy and Rodney Allen Morris